As Yearn.Finance’s yield vaults grow, ‘crop’ projects define boundaries

As Yearn.Finance’s yield vaults grow, ‘crop’ projects define boundaries

With millions and even billions of dollars at stake, industrial-scale yield farming is leading to pockets of resistance as some projects refuse to be left with the chaff. 

In the past week, team members from no-loss lottery project PoolTogether and exchange liquidity pool provider Curve Finance have proposed ways to reduce the load Yearn.Finance strategies place on their protocols and governance tokens.

Our top trading bots

In a Tweet on Sunday, PoolTogether co-founder Leighton Cusak noted that Yearn has become the primary beneficiary of many of the protocol’s DAI lotteries, as Yearn controls 57% of all DAI funds ($27 million of the $47 million in the pool at the time of writing) and therefore has a disproportionate chance to win.

“At this scale, it becomes problematic as they monopolize the chances to win and marginalize the core value prop of the protocol,” Cusak wrote on Twitter.

Likewise, in a governance proposal today “Charlie,” a representative of the Curve core team, put forth a vote to remove the CRV benefits given to the alUSD pool. alUSD is a stablecoin from Alchemix, a project which issues loans based on future yield from deposits into Yearn vaults; Yearn vaults, in turn, use stablecoins and other assets to farm Curve’s CRV token.

Both instances of projects bucking under Yearn’s weight led to speculation on social media that there may be personal hostilities motivating what looks like a protocol-level sharecropper’s revolt (Alchemix opted to use Curve competitor Saddle for a new synthetic ETH pool); that Yearn may be overzealous with its farm-and-dump strategies; and that there could be “governance wars” creating friction in what should be an open ecosystem. 

Likening the dynamic to a “war” appears to be overblown, however.

In an interview with Cointelegraph, Cusack said that PoolTogether has already agreed to onboard Yearn as an interest provider for the lotteries, and in turn Yearn will cease acting as a whale flopping in their pools. 

“We have recently completed an integration with yearn and it is being audited. This means our prizes pools can use Yearn for yield. This is better as it will yield a higher APR. It also means that Yearn won't be able to deposit into PoolTogether as that would create a risky recursive loop,” he said.

He also noted that “Yearn keeps 10% of all the POOL tokens it accrues” and that POOL emissions were cut 50% late last month.

“I've found them to be very helpful and willing to make changes to reach a more optimum outcome.They ultimately understand that our success brings more success to them,” Cusak added of the Yearn team.

Likewise, Charlie of Curve noted that the governance proposal is an effort to mitigate a recursive CRV emission structure, similar to what PoolTogether is looking to achieve with their new arrangement.

“Alchemix and alUSD are awesome products which partly make their yield by selling CRV which is why the community raised the point [they] shouldn't receive CRV on top (the double dipping). It is not a hostile proposal towards Alchemix, just a way to see if the rest of the Curve DAO feels the same way about it and if they indeed do feel like it's abusing the system. It has nothing to do with the selling,” he said.

While the battle between farmer and crops for the time appears to have been staved off, Cusak did say that there remains a fundamental conflict that could eventually bubble into a governance fight.

“There is inherently a tension between protocols wanting deposits to drive growth and those depositors wanting to maximize yield be selling the protocol token.”

While the DeFi ecosystem prides itself on elegant economic designs and logical systems, when it comes to governance hot heads do sometimes lead to conflicts. Earlier in the year, insurance/coverage protocol Cover and Yearn.Finance announced a cessation of a merger that some parties likened to a divorce. 

Multiple Yearn reps did not respond by the time of publication.

Read on about Cointelegraph
Price analysis 6/18: BTC, ETH, BNB, ADA, DOGE, XRP, DOT, UNI, LTC, BCH
The U.S. Federal Reserve updated their inflation expectations for this year from 2.4% in March to 3.4% in their latest meeting that concluded on June 16....
Community-governed DEX EmiSwap raises $104M in private funding
EmiSwap — a community-governed decentralized exchange (DEX) — has raised $104 million from a large number of investors, each of whom put down a maximum...
XRP Jumps 21% In Bullish Trade
Investing.com - XRP was trading at $1.09285 by 20:38 (00:38 GMT) on the Investing.com Index on Tuesday, up 20.61% on the day. It was the largest one-day...
Cardano Climbs 13% As Investors Gain Confidence
Investing.com - Cardano was trading at $1.796203 by 07:41 (11:41 GMT) on the Investing.com Index on Thursday, up 13.36% on the day. It was the largest one-day...
EOS Falls 37% In Rout
Investing.com - EOS was trading at $5.4878 by 21:50 (01:50 GMT) on the Investing.com Index on Thursday, down 36.77% on the day. It was the largest one-day...
UAE employs blockchain tech for remote litigation services
The government of the United Arab Emirates will employ blockchain technology for use in its judicial notarization and authentication services, it announced...
VORTECS Report: Storage coins rev up gains as Markets Pro rides the green wave
It’s been another great week for altcoins as the total market capitalization of all cryptocurrencies moves within spitting distance of the $2 trillion mark.And...
UK crypto firms must now submit yearly financial crimes reports
The United Kingdom's Financial Conduct Authority has included cryptoasset businesses under the financial crimes reporting umbrella eight months after initially...
China and Japan go full steam ahead with CBDC pilots
China and Japan are pushing forward with their respective pilots for central bank-issued digital currencies, or CBDCs.On March 26, Bank of Japan announced...
VCs bet big on layer-two as StarkWare raises a staggering $75 million
As Ethereum gas fees soar and the demand for scalability reaches fever pitch, layer-two scaling solution has announced today a $75 million Series B funding...
Jeff Garzik’s DeFi protocol Vesper Finance tops $1B TVL in six weeks
Vesper Finance, a recently launched DeFI yield suite co-founded by former Bitcoin core developer Jeff Garzik, has surpassed a TVL of $1 billion within six...
The World Celebrating 8th Bitcoin Pizza Day With an Order Worth $83 mln
Eight years ago happened something which can indeed be called revolutionary. On May 22, 2010, there was bought the first in the entire world pizza for...
Facebook, Instagram Ban Ads on Bitcoin and ICOs As ‘Deceptive Practices’
Around a month ago Facebook CEO and co-founder Mark Zuckerberg promised to look into crypto technologies, as well as to work on the errors that the company...
Nasdaq Is Looking Into Crypto Futures That Are Distinct From Rivals, CEO Confirms
Not long ago, Morgan Stanley decided to follow the lead of Goldman Sachs in clearing bitcoin-based futures. Meanwhile, more than a month ago two large...
Zuckerberg Considers Future Integration of Cryptos Tech in Facebook
One of the wealthiest and most influential people in the world, the Facebook co-founder and its CEO Mark Zuckerberg displayed his desire to weigh in the...