Federal judge's decision could be a blow for the privacy rights of crypto users

Federal judge's decision could be a blow for the privacy rights of crypto users

A federal judge has implied that an individual may not have the right to force the Internal Revenue Service, or IRS, to expunge financial records it obtains from crypto exchanges.

In granting a motion to dismiss filed in December, Judge Joseph DiClerico in the District of New Hampshire suggested the Internal Revenue Service has no obligation to honor requests to purge crypto transaction records it received from Coinbase or other exchanges regarding information for federal taxes. Dismissed in part for lack of jurisdiction, the civil rights case filed by plaintiff James Harper against IRS commissioner Charles Rettig, the agency, and its officers concluded after almost a year in court.

Our top trading bots

Today's dismissal said that Harper was not entitled to compensation for damages, or to limit the IRS’ ability to obtain tax information from the exchanges, mainly due to the Anti-Injunction Act. Only applicable to federal taxes, the statute prevents federal courts from exercising jurisdiction in certain cases to hinder "the assessment or collection of any tax.”

"The effect of Harper's requested declaratory and injunctive relief would be to prevent the IRS from assessing Harper's or others' taxes using the information it has obtained through the John Doe third-party process," said Judge DiClerico. "Consequently, his suit, to the extent it seeks injunctive and declaratory relief, is barred by the Anti-Injunction Act."

Harper had an account at Coinbase starting in 2013, first receiving Bitcoin (BTC) deposits as income for consulting work. He claims that he declared the crypto transactions under capital gains on his tax returns until 2016, when he had liquidated and transferred any holdings off the exchange, as well as any BTC on Abra and Uphold.

In 2019, the IRS sent 10,000 letters to crypto investors clarifying the tax filing requirements for digital assets and seemingly suggesting they pay any undeclared back taxes. The letter included a veiled threat of crypto users being "subject to future civil and criminal enforcement activity" should they not properly declare and pay taxes on holdings.

Harper had reportedly not held any crypto on Coinbase since 2016, and the exchange said in its terms of agreement that it would protect users’ personal information from "loss, misuse, unauthorized access, disclosure, alteration, and destruction." However, because he had received the IRS letter, Harper inferred that either Abra or Coinbase — or both — had provided his personal information to the agency. In July 2020, he filed a civil rights lawsuit against the IRS, alleging the tax agency violated his Fourth and Fifth Amendment rights.

Court documents referenced a federal case with Coinbase from 2017, which said the IRS obtaining personal financial information from the exchange was classified as “tax compliance, not research" that “serves the legitimate investigative purpose of enforcing the tax laws against those who profit from trading in virtual currency." That decision, as well as the one today, may suggest that crypto users have little recourse should an exchange like Coinbase turn over their personal information in response to a subpoena or request for information from the IRS.

The judge’s decision comes just three weeks prior to the deadline for filing taxes in the United States, April 15.

Read on relating to Cointelegraph
Bitcoin records all-time high network difficulty amid price fluctuations
The Bitcoin (BTC) network has recorded a new all-time high mining difficulty of 26.643 trillion with an average hash rate of 190.71 exahash per second (EH/s)...
Bitcoin mining manufacturer Canaan expands footprint in Kazakhstan
Bitcoin (BTC) mining hardware manufacturer Canaan Inc is expanding its footprint in Kazakhstan after signing new strategic partnerships with multiple crypto...
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez says US lawmakers shouldn't hold crypto to 'remain impartial'
Democratic lawmaker Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez said Monday that she avoids any and all investments which could potentially represent a conflict of interest,...
Traders watch for a trend reversal after Ethereum price drops to $4,100
Ether (ETH) traders might have a few reasons to panic after today's 13% drop down to $4,100. The swift pullback appears to have broken a 55-day ascending...
Next generation of crypto millionaires: SHIB allows warehouse manager to retire
A Shiba Inu token holder who invested thousands of dollars in the memecoin in February has partially cashed out to become a stay-at-home dad.According to...
Altcoin Roundup: Holding Bitcoin? Here’s how to put it to work in DeFi
The long-awaited day finally came on Oct. 19 as the first Bitcoin (BTC) exchange-traded fund (ETF) went live on the New York Stock Exchange, thrusting the...
Old FUD, new BTC price dip — Weeks-old China crypto ‘ban’ sparks Bitcoin price drop to $42K
Bitcoin (BTC) suddenly lost $2,000 in an hour on Sept. 24 as what appeared to be old news over a Chinese regulatory ban hit social media.BTC/USD 1-hour...
'Crypto Mom' Hester Peirce slams SEC for $10m Poloniex settlement
Commissioner Hester Peirce, known colloquially as “Crypto Mom,” has slammed the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) for its $10 million settlement...
Goldman Sach's new 'DeFi' ETF is anything but
The proposed fund, dubbed the Goldman Sachs Innovate DeFi and Blockchain Equity ETF, strives to track the Decentralized Finance and Blockchain Index from...
Chinese social media giant Weibo reportedly bans crypto-related accounts
China’s crackdown on cryptocurrencies has reportedly spread to social media. Weibo, China’s Twitter-like microblogging service with over 530 million monthly...
Two-fifths of Aussie millennials think crypto investments beat real estate
Research has revealed that one in five Australians believe that crypto is the key to homeownership as confidence in traditional savings dwindles.The survey,...
Digital yuan conceived to counter Alipay-like platforms, says former PBoC executive
China’s digital yuan will utilize smart contracts, and will be built to counter Alipay-like payment platforms designed by the privately-owned conglomerates,...
Bridgewater Associates CFO heads to Bitcoin-focused firm
Departing his position as the chief financial officer of Bridgewater Associates, John Dalby will assume the post of chief financial officer for Bitcoin-focused...
NASA Will Create An Unmanned Spacecraft That Will "Think" Thanks To AI And The Blockchain
NASA began a new research project, which plans to use artificial intelligence and a blockchain for the intelligent system of an unmanned spacecraft. The...
Cryptobanks vs. Centralized Rivals: Who Will Win?
Several analysts have already expressed their belief concerning the hopeless future for traditional banks and payment systems once bitcoin and its brethren...